What to do about an unfair or fake review

Some reviews are unfair, a few are fake, and many are simply harsh. They need different handling, and getting it wrong makes things worse.

By Christopher Ross · 4 minute read · Updated 2026-11-21

The short version

  • Google removes reviews that break its content policies. Harsh or unfair is not enough.
  • Check your records first. Many 'fake' reviews turn out to be real customers.
  • Report real violations, and still reply calmly in the meantime. Review evaluation typically takes several days.
  • Never threaten, retaliate or post fake reviews in return. In the US that can break the FTC's reviews rule.

Not every bad review is a fake one. Most are real customers who had a worse time than you meant them to have.

A few are mistaken, a few are malicious, and fewer still are fake. They need different handling, and the wrong one can make things worse.

Three kinds of bad review

A bad review is harsh but real, mistaken, or fake, and each needs a different response.

Harsh but real

The customer was there, and their view is unfair or exaggerated. You cannot remove it, because being unfair is not a policy violation.

Answer it calmly. Readers can usually tell when a reviewer is being unreasonable, and a polite reply makes that clearer.

Mistaken

The review is about another business, another branch or something you do not do. Say so politely and invite them to check. If it is clearly about a different business, you can report it as off-topic.

Fake or abusive

There is no record of the customer, the review comes from a competitor or an ex-employee, it contains threats, hate or private information, or several reviews arrive together with similar wording. These may break the site's policies and can be reported.

Have a reply drafted already? Try the draft check alongside this guide. It is free, with no sign-up.

Start with the records

Check your own records first, before you reply or report anything.

Flow chart: check your records. If you find the customer, reply calmly. If you cannot, reply politely and report if it breaks policy. If it contains threats or hate, report it and do not argue.
Check first, then decide. A calm reply protects you while the site decides.

Before you decide a review is fake, look for the name, the date, the order or the booking. Ask staff. A surprising number of "fake" reviews turn out to be a real customer using a different name or a partner's account.

Signs a review may be fake

These signs suggest a review may not come from a real customer, but none is proof on its own.

  • You cannot find the person, the date or the order.
  • The reviewer has posted only one review, or many one-star reviews of competitors.
  • It describes services you do not offer.
  • A cluster of similar reviews arrives in a short time.
  • The language is generic, or the same phrases appear in other reviews.

These are clues, not proof. Do not accuse anyone in public.

What Google will and will not remove

Google's policy covers many kinds of content it removes, including fake engagement, rating manipulation, advertising and solicitation, repetitive content, off-topic content, misrepresentation, impersonation, and harassment and offensive content. It also says merchants may not discourage negative reviews or selectively solicit positive ones. It also treats content based on a conflict of interest as a violation. A review that follows the policies is not eligible for removal, however much it stings.

How to report a review on Google

You report a review from the review itself, and these steps show how.

For what happens after you report, see can you delete a Google review.

  1. Open your Business Profile reviews.
  2. Next to the review, select Report.
  3. Choose the reason that fits and send the report.
  4. Watch the status. You may see "Decision pending", "Report reviewed - no policy violation" or "Escalated".

Google says review evaluation typically takes several days. If the answer is no, Google offers a single appeal covering up to ten reviews, so gather your evidence before you use it. For content you believe is unlawful, such as a defamatory statement, Google has a separate legal removal form, and it says to flag the review in the product first.

A reply that works

Reply politely, state the facts and invite the reviewer to contact you.

"Thank you for the feedback. We have looked for a record of this visit and cannot find one, so I wonder whether the review was meant for another business. If you were a customer, please contact me at [email] with the date and any details, and I will look into it. [First name]"

It is polite, it states a fact and it leaves the door open. It does not call anyone a liar.

What not to do

Do not argue, threaten or retaliate. The lists below show what to do instead.

Do

  • Save screenshots of the review and the reviewer's profile.
  • Report each review against the specific policy it breaks.
  • Reply once, calmly.
  • Keep collecting real reviews.

Do not

  • Post a fake review in return, or ask friends to counter it.
  • Threaten the reviewer with legal action you do not intend to take.
  • Offer money or a discount in return for removal.
  • Reveal the customer's order, appointment or health details.

The law is on both sides of this. The US FTC's rule on reviews and testimonials, in force since 21 October 2024, bans writing or selling fake reviews and also bans using unfounded or groundless legal threats, intimidation or knowingly false accusations to suppress a review. In Canada the Competition Bureau has said that anyone who writes or permits reviews that give a false or misleading impression could be liable. If a review is seriously damaging, take advice from a lawyer before you act. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

Do not let it change how you ask

The best defence against one unfair review is a steady flow of real ones. See how to ask customers for reviews within the rules, and use the response templates when the next one arrives. For the full method on a review that is real but harsh, read how to respond to a negative review.

Sources and further reading

Policies change. Check the linked page for the current wording before you build a process around it.

Common questions

Can I get a bad review removed?

Only if it violates the site's content policies, such as fake engagement, off-topic content, harassment or a conflict of interest. A review that follows the policies stays up, even if you think it is unfair.

How do I report a review on Google?

Open your Business Profile reviews, select Report next to the review, pick the reason and send it. Google then evaluates it, which typically takes several days. Google offers one appeal, for up to ten reviews.

Should I reply to a review I think is fake?

Yes, once, calmly. Say you cannot find a record of the visit and invite them to get in touch. Do not accuse them.

Can I sue over a fake review?

Sometimes, but it is slow and costly and the outcome is uncertain. If a review makes a false and damaging claim, talk to a lawyer before replying in a way that escalates. Also note that a groundless legal threat aimed at making someone take a review down can itself violate the FTC's US rule.

What about a competitor posting fake reviews?

Report each one with the specific policy it breaks, keep screenshots, and note patterns such as several new accounts with similar wording. In the US the FTC rule also bans buying and selling fake reviews. In Canada the Competition Bureau has said that misleading reviews can create liability.

Does the review count against me while it is pending?

In general a reported review stays visible until the site decides, so plan on it being seen for a while. That is why a calm public reply matters.