Review reply mistakes to avoid, and what to say instead

Most bad replies come from the same few habits. Here are the phrases to leave out and a better way to say each one.

By Christopher Ross · 2 minute read · Updated 2026-11-21

The short version

  • The most common reply mistakes are defending yourself, blaming the customer, promising money in public and sharing private details.
  • Replace each one with a fact, an apology for the part that is yours and one way to talk privately.
  • When the customer is right, say so plainly in one sentence. Do not over-apologise.
  • Read your reply aloud before you post. If it sounds like an argument, rewrite it.

Most bad replies come from the same few habits. They feel natural when you are annoyed, and they look worse to everyone who reads them later. Here are the habits to avoid, with a better version of each.

Ten phrases to leave out

Each phrase below has a safer way to say the same thing.

Instead ofTryWhy
"That never happened.""I cannot find a record of this, and I would like to understand."It accuses the customer.
"You were rude to my staff.""I am sorry the visit felt tense. Please contact me so I can hear your side."Blaming staff matters or the customer in public escalates it.
"We will refund you in full.""Please contact me at [email] so I can look into this."Money is a private matter, and public promises can be screenshotted.
"As you can see from our policy...""I understand why that was frustrating."It sounds like a lawyer.
"We are sorry you feel that way.""I am sorry we let you down on [the problem]."It sounds like a non-apology.
"Our staff did nothing wrong.""I will talk with the team about what happened."Defending hides what you can learn.
"Come back and we will make it right.""Please contact me so I can make this right."It asks for a second chance in public instead of a private conversation.
"We have 4.8 stars, so...""Thank you for the honest feedback."It dismisses the reviewer.
Their full name, order number or dateTheir first name only, or noneEveryone can read it.
The same paragraph on every reviewOne changed phrase and one real detailA pasted reply reads like a script.

Have a reply drafted already? Try the draft check alongside this guide. It is free, with no sign-up.

When the customer is right

Say so once, plainly, and say what you will change. Do not over-apologise, and do not make a long speech.

"You are right, [name]. We should have told you about the delay, and we did not. I am changing how we keep customers informed. If you would like to talk, please contact me at [email]."

Only promise what you will do. If you cannot change something, say that instead.

When you think the review is unfair

Stay factual. Say what you cannot find, invite the person to get in touch and do not accuse them.

"Thank you for the feedback. We have looked for a record of this visit and cannot find one, so I wonder whether it was meant for another business. If we have it wrong, please contact me at [email]."

If you believe it breaks Google's policies, see what to do about an unfair or fake review.

A quick check before you post

Run through these five questions, then post.

  1. Does it name a fact from the review, and not a guess?
  2. Does it avoid blame, money and private details?
  3. Does it give one way to talk offline?
  4. Would you be comfortable if a future customer read it?
  5. Does it sound like a person, not a script?

For ready wording, see the review response templates and how to respond to a negative review. The draft check reads your text for these risks before you post.

Sources and further reading

Policies change. Check the linked page for the current wording before you build a process around it.

Common questions

What is the biggest mistake in a reply to a bad review?

Arguing. The reply is read by future customers, and an argument makes the business look defensive even when it was right.

Should I apologise if I think I did nothing wrong?

You can say you are sorry the customer had a poor experience without admitting fault. Then state the facts calmly and invite them to contact you.

Can I offer a refund in my reply?

Do not offer money or gifts in public. Take the conversation offline. Google also prohibits offering incentives to change or remove a negative review.

Is it a mistake to reply to every review the same way?

Yes. A pasted reply looks like a script. Change at least one phrase and add one detail from the review.